Mitchell defense documents unsealed

Information about his competency, mental health included

Published: Thursday, Nov. 5, 2009 9:40 p.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 

Defense motions in the federal case of Brian David Mitchell that had been previously kept out of the public eye were unsealed Thursday.

One of the unsealed motions Thursday was a 36-page memorandum seeking to exclude the testimony of Dr. Michael Welner from Mitchell's upcoming competency hearing and another 24-page memorandum in support of the motion.

Welner, a renowned forensic psychiatrist from New York City, is the government's key witness during Mitchell's competency hearing scheduled to resume Nov. 30. He has prepared what some consider to be the most extensive report on Mitchell to date, and said he believes Mitchell is competent to stand trial.

The motion re-states what had previously been released that Welner believes Mitchell is neither "schizophrenic nor suffering from delusional disorder, but that rather, among other things, that Mr. Mitchell is instead malingering," according to court documents.

Welner also concluded that Mitchell suffered from pedophilia, nonexclusive type, antisocial personality disorder, narcissistic personality disorder, malingering and alcohol abuse but was not mentally incompetent to stand trial.

Story continues below

Welner's report is inadmissible, according to court documents filed by Mitchell's attorneys, because it is not based on sufficient facts outlined under federal rules and "omits facts and findings contrary to Dr. Welner's conclusion."

Mitchell further claims the report omits key information from the Utah State Hospital, such as the conclusions from Mitchell's treating physician at the hospital.

The motion examines four elements of Welner's report on Mitchell, including Mitchell's word fasts, his singing, Mitchell's belief that the court system is corrupt and his alleged escape plan from the Utah State Hospital.

In regard to their client's singing in court, the defense believes Welner's report "omits consideration of the possibility … of Mr. Mitchell's actual faith, rational or otherwise, in the power of hymn, which, in this instance, could just as readily be interpreted as Mr. Mitchell's reliance and belief in a God who would counteract what Mr. Mitchell perceives as a corrupt system."

The defense motion revealed other tidbits about Mitchell and how he refused to use the state hospital's soap or toothpaste because they were the products of a corrupt system, as was the government, the judicial system and industries such as the meat industry.

Recent comments

Any assertion by the defense that this 200+ page synthesis, which has...

Consider this | Nov. 6, 2009 at 5:06 p.m.

Mitchell is clearly competent because of the great detail of his...

Clearly competent | Nov. 6, 2009 at 8:23 a.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

That game was amazing! I think this will really help the sport grow in Utah....

Real Champions

Congrats on a great win. Utah as a whole should be proud not just of a major...

Congrats Real Salt Lake! but, they aren't the first major sports team to...

RSL regroups, dominates 2nd half

I told ALL of you how much i liked NED Pure irony his contributions vs x...

RSL wins MLS Cup on penalty kicks

this is to NevadaUTE @ 10:25!!! I love soccer, I love Real and it brought a...

Real Champions

wow!!! amazing. UTAH JAZZ DO SOMETHING!!!

Glenn Beck to enter politics?

So much fear and anger from Beck lovers. You all lost the last election, we...

RSL wins MLS Cup on penalty kicks

This is the most emotion I have had watching a sporting event since my...

Nicky Rimando is my hero! I love that guy. He has had his detractors, but...

Real Champions

Two stars means nothing! We played as a team and it showed! I'm still in...

Advertisements