Mitchell documents to be unsealed

Published: Saturday, Oct. 31, 2009 10:23 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 

Prosecutors and defense attorneys in the federal case of Brian David Mitchell have agreed to unseal motions filed in relation to Mitchell's competency hearing that will determine whether he can be tried in the kidnapping of Elizabeth Smart.

In what was considered by some lawyers to be an "anti-climatic" hearing over what was expected to be a fight over public access to court records, attorneys for both sides had apparently reached an agreement prior to Friday's hearing.

"Today was a good day for the principle of public access to the courts," said attorney Michael O'Brien, who represented the media interveners, including the Deseret News, who sought to have the court documents unsealed.

The official decision to unseal the motions, however, will come from U.S. District Judge Dale Kimball, who took the arguments presented in court under advisement.

Friday's hearing was to determine which documents, if any, should remain sealed relating to Mitchell's competency hearing. One of those defense motions was for sanctions against the U.S. Attorney's Office for not filing its own responses under seal. That motion was dropped Friday by the defense.

"We firmly believe everybody has done what they've done in good faith," said Bob Steele, with the Utah Federal Defenders Office.

Story continues below

The other three defense motions in question, which could be opened immediately pending Kimball's ruling, include motions to suppress the testimonies of all lay witnesses, Dr. Michael Welner and Mitchell himself.

Both sides agreed that those motions should be opened but with certain redactions.

The items that would be redacted would include any graphic details of the alleged sexual assaults on Smart, as well as names of patients at the Utah State Hospital or additional minor victims. Also Friday, Kimball ordered Mitchell's arrest warrant unsealed immediately, which contained no new information. Originally, Friday's hearing was closed to the public. Kimball opened it after a request from the media.

On Monday, Kimball ordered 16 court-docket entries in the case opened. O'Brien pointed out to Kimball on Friday that there was still a mystery docket entry with undisclosed content. Kimball said he would investigate.

Two sealed reports from the Department of Prisons were also discussed Friday. The reports were believed to be competency evaluations from Welner and Dr. Richart DeMier, who examined Mitchell last year after he was sent to a federal facility in Springfield, Mo., for a competency evaluation. Both sides agreed to also open any portion of those reports that were admitted as evidence during Mitchell's competency hearing, but not until after the hearing was over.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

That game was amazing! I think this will really help the sport grow in Utah....

Real Champions

Congrats on a great win. Utah as a whole should be proud not just of a major...

Congrats Real Salt Lake! but, they aren't the first major sports team to...

RSL regroups, dominates 2nd half

I told ALL of you how much i liked NED Pure irony his contributions vs x...

RSL wins MLS Cup on penalty kicks

this is to NevadaUTE @ 10:25!!! I love soccer, I love Real and it brought a...

Real Champions

wow!!! amazing. UTAH JAZZ DO SOMETHING!!!

Glenn Beck to enter politics?

So much fear and anger from Beck lovers. You all lost the last election, we...

RSL wins MLS Cup on penalty kicks

This is the most emotion I have had watching a sporting event since my...

Nicky Rimando is my hero! I love that guy. He has had his detractors, but...

Real Champions

Two stars means nothing! We played as a team and it showed! I'm still in...

Advertisements